| 
                     
                      |  | VIRGINIA 
                          FREEDOM OF INFORMATION 
                          ADVISORY COUNCILCOMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA
 |  
 2020 
                    Subcommittees The 
                    2020 Session of the General Assembly referred one bill to 
                    the FOIA Council for study during the interim. The FOIA Council 
                    also continued its Phishing Study which was referred by the 
                    2019 Session of the General Assembly. At its meeting on August 
                    4, 2020, the FOIA Council established two subcommittees to 
                    study these bills as described below. 1. HB 321 
                    - Electronic Meetings Subcommittee The 
                    Subcommittee consists of Council members Coleburn, Conrad, 
                    Potter, Rives, Seltzer, Stern, and Wade. The Subcommittee 
                    will study House 
                    Bill 321 (Levine), summarized as follows:  
                    Virginia 
                      Freedom of Information Act; electronic meetings; serious 
                      medical condition of immediate family member. Allows 
                      a public body to conduct a meeting through electronic communication 
                      means if, on or before the day of a meeting, a member of 
                      the public body holding the meeting notifies the chair of 
                      the public body that he is unable to attend due to a serious 
                      medical condition of an immediate family member that prevents 
                      the member's physical attendance. The bill also limits such 
                      participation in an electronic meeting due to a personal 
                      matter to either two meetings per calendar year or 10 percent 
                      of the meetings held that calendar year, rounded up to the 
                      nearest whole number, whichever is greater. The 
                    Subcommittee will also study other issues related to electronic 
                    meetings as needed, including issues which have been raised 
                    due to the COVID-19 state of emergency Redline 
                    Draft for Consideration (pdf) Redline 
                    Draft for Consideration (Word doc) Meetings 
                    Scheduled: 
                      Tuesday, 
                    October 20, 2020, 1:15 p.m., Virtual MeetingAgenda
 Summary
 Meeting Video 
                    (mp4)
 VCOG Remarks
 Further VCOG Remarks
 VPA Remarks
 Aimee Perron 
                    Siebert Remarks
 Jon Stehle Remarks
 Jennifer Passey 
                    Remarks
 Lauren Colliver 
                    Remarks
 Susan 
                    Anderson Remarks
 Joseph Swartz 
                    Remarks
 Elizabeth 
                    Bennett-Parker Remarks
 Phyllis Errico 
                    Remarks
 Wednesday, 
                    November 18, 2020, 2:00 p.m., Virtual MeetingAgenda
 Summary
 Meeting Video
 Bill draft for 
                    discussion
 Alternative draft
 Draft Received from 
                    Aimee Perron Siebert
 American Association 
                    of University Women of Virginia Comments
 Comment letter 
                    submitted on behalf of 32 elected women
 Comments 
                    submitted on behalf of the City of Falls Church Council
 VPA Remarks
 Jacqueline Wilson 
                    Remarks
 Abby 
                    Fox Remarks
 Liz Carter 
                    Remarks
 Lara Larson 
                    Remarks
 Amanda Bean 
                    Remarks
 Shirley 
                    Hottot Remarks
 Stair Calhoun 
                    Remarks
 Stair Calhoun 
                    Remarks (2)
 Jere Gibber 
                    Remarks
 Jay Sinha Remarks
 Lucy Von Fahnestock 
                    Remarks
 Alyia Gaskins 
                    Remarks
 Lindsey 
                    Davis Stover Remarks
 Larysa Kautz
 Candice 
                    Bennett Remarks
 Melssa Dart 
                    Remarks
 Allison 
                    Byrne Remarks
 Allison 
                    Jenkins/Allison Byrne Remarks
 Irina Khanin 
                    Remarks
 Michelle 
                    Woolley Remarks
 Natalie Pien 
                    Remarks
 Heather 
                    Allen Remarks
 Chelsea 
                    Savage Remarks
 Julie Jakopic 
                    Remarks
 Linda Mccray 
                    Remarks
 Tricia Dunlap 
                    Remarks
 Rosa Castillo 
                    Krewson Remarks
 Harriet 
                    Hirsch Remarks
 Mindy Mitchell 
                    Remarks
 Shafuq Naseem 
                    Remarks
 Ashley 
                    Marshall Remarks
 Katherine Seifu 
                    Remarks
 Katie Cristol 
                    Remarks
 Helen Cole 
                    Remarks
 Arbora 
                    Johnson
 Stephen 
                    D'Alessio Remarks
 Vicki Moffitt 
                    Remarks
 Yvette Jiang 
                    Remarks
 Annette Lang 
                    Remarks
 David Tartar 
                    (NVRC) Remarks
 Catherine 
                    Lada Remarks
 Kim Keene Remarks
 Diana Karczmarczyk 
                    Remarks
 Nicole Carry 
                    Remarks
 Bonnie 
                    Hershberg Remarks
 Norma Kacen 
                    Remarks
 Hannah Senft 
                    Remarks
 Kathryn 
                    Scruggs Remarks
 Lauren Smith 
                    Remarks
 Amanda 
                    Granozio Remarks
 Gary 
                    Grant Remarks
 William 
                    Tufts Remarks
 Susana 
                    Gonzalez
 Karmel James 
                    Remarks
 Mikhael 
                    Charnoff Remarks
 Margaret 
                    Turlington Remarks
 Meghan Goldenberg 
                    Remarks
 Lauren Gedge 
                    Remarks
 Erin Gill Remarks
 Debra Roth 
                    Remarks
 Molly Novotny 
                    Remarks
 Cory Weiss 
                    Remarks
 Chrystie 
                    Swiney Remarks
 Kathleen 
                    Philpott Costa Remarks
 Susan 
                    Nelson Remarks
 Leanne 
                    Berthiaume Remarks
 Linda 
                    Valentino Remarks
 Alisa Macht 
                    Remarks
 Meredith 
                    MacKay Remarks
 Liz Weatherly 
                    Remarks
 Christina 
                    Goodwin Remarks
 Susana Hill 
                    Remarks
 Ruth Saunders 
                    Remarks
 Stephanie 
                    Oppenheimer Remarks
 Remarks submitted 
                    on behalf of the Virginia chapter of the National Organization 
                    for Women
 Elizabeth Lonoff 
                    Remarks
 Connie 
                    Rydberg Remarks
 Kristina 
                    Martinez Remarks
 Maria 
                    del Carmen Cadena Almeida Remarks
 Jorge Ricardo 
                    Bolanos Gamboa Remarks
 Sandra 
                    Tarpinian Remarks
 Melissa 
                    Teates Remarks
 Ricardo 
                    Alfaro Remarks
 Stacy Evers 
                    Remarks
 Douglas 
                    Bolanos Remarks
 Andy Rankin 
                    Remarks
 Archi Pyati 
                    Remarks
 Maureen 
                    Devine-Ahl Remarks
 Courtney 
                    Newbold Remarks
 Lauren Miller 
                    Remarks
 Kelli Edwards 
                    Remarks
 Andrea 
                    Caumont Remarks
 Sonia Ruiz-Bolanos 
                    Remarks
 Paige Halper 
                    Remarks
 Corey 
                    Jannicelli Remarks
 Megan Bartholomew 
                    Remarks
 David Beddoe 
                    Remarks
 Carl Salsbury 
                    Remarks
 Lisa Bockelman 
                    Remarks
 Monica Freas 
                    Remarks
 Leslie Rye 
                    Remarks
 Susanna 
                    Hamme Remarks
 Kristin 
                    Stamilio Remarks
 Brittanie 
                    Werbel Remarks
 Jenna Shroeder 
                    Remarks
 Catharine 
                    Rice Remarks
 Cathy Hosek 
                    Remarks
 Ann Smith Remarks
 Drew Meren 
                    Remarks
 Norman Hall 
                    Remarks
 Barbara 
                    Brown Remarks
 David Swan 
                    Remarks
 Jess Stewart 
                    Remarks
 Karen Akers 
                    Remarks
 Vee Maddox 
                    Remarks
 Lisa Connolly 
                    Remarks
 Missy Dixon 
                    Remarks
 Holly Hazard 
                    Remarks
 Megan Radek 
                    Remarks
 Kathi Robinson 
                    Remarks
 William 
                    Berkson Remarks
 Kelly Daly 
                    Remarks
 Rupa Hicks 
                    Remarks
 Carrie Bruns 
                    Remarks
 Letter 
                    submmitted on behalf of 61 elected officials
 Shea Cousin 
                    Remarks
 Ann Wyborski 
                    Remarks
 Mia Tilman 
                    Remarks
 Richard 
                    McPike Remarks
 Cathy Copeland 
                    Remarks
 2. HJ 628 
                    - Phishing Study Subcommittee
 The 
                    Subcommittee consists of Council members Treadway (Chair), 
                    Bujakowski, King-Casey, Rives, and Wade. The Subcommittee 
                    will study the threat of phishing attacks using information 
                    obtained through FOIA as proposed by House 
                    Joint Resolution 628 (Heretick, 2019), summarized as follows: 
                      
                    Study; 
                      Virginia Freedom of Information Advisory Council; threat 
                      of phishing attacks; report. Directs the Virginia 
                      Freedom of Information Advisory Council (FOIA Council) to 
                      study the threat of phishing attacks on citizens and public 
                      employees whose contact and private information is legally 
                      obtained as a result of a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) 
                      request. The study further directs the FOIA Council to examine 
                      the current FOIA provisions and make recommendations on 
                      ways to address the threat of phishing attacks on citizens 
                      and public employees of the Commonwealth. [NOTE: 
                    Please click here 
                    to view the work of the Subcommittee in 2019.] Meetings 
                    Scheduled: Tuesday, 
                    November 17, 2020, 11:00 a.m., Virtual MeetingAgenda
 Summary
 Meeting Video
 Roger 
                    Wiley Remarks
 
 3. 
                    HB 5090 - Criminal Incident Information Subcommittee
 The 
                    Subcommittee consists of Council members Delegate Simon (Chair), 
                    Conrad, King-Casey, Seltzer, and an additional citizen member, 
                    Marisa Porto. The Subcommittee will study House 
                    Bill 5090 (Hurst), summarized as follows:   
                    Virginia 
                      Freedom of Information Act; law-enforcement criminal incident 
                      information; criminal investigative files. Adds 
                      criminal investigative files, defined in the bill, to the 
                      types of law-enforcement and criminal records required to 
                      be released in accordance with the provisions of the Virginia 
                      Freedom of Information Act. Under current law, the release 
                      of criminal investigative files is discretionary. The bill 
                      also allows a law-enforcement agency or attorney for the 
                      Commonwealth to petition a court of record for permission 
                      not to release criminal incident information that would 
                      otherwise be subject to release, if the release of such 
                      information is likely to jeopardize an ongoing investigation 
                      or cause certain other harms. Meetings 
                    Scheduled: Wednesday, 
                    October 21, 2020, 2:00 p.m., Virtual MeetingAgenda
 Summary
 Meeting Video 
                    (mp4)
 Innocence 
                    Project's proposed legislation
 Summary 
                    of National Landscape on Public Access to Criminal Investigative 
                    Files
 50 State Analysis 
                    of Public Access to Criminal Investigative Files
 Written 
                    Testimony from victim family members Jason Nixon & Debbie 
                    Borato
 Innocence 
                    Project Testimony from Michelle Feldman
 VCOG 
                    Remarks
 
 Tuesday, 
                    November 17, 2020, 2:00 p.m., Virtual MeetingAgenda
 Summary
 Meeting 
                    Video (mp4)
 Bill draft for discussion
 Virginia 
                    Innocence Coalition Testimony
 Jason Nixon Testimony
 Debbie Borato Testimony
     
 |