|
|
VIRGINIA FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ADVISORY COUNCIL
COMMONWEALTH
OF VIRGINIA |
AO-12-26
October
21, 2026
Mr.
Buddy Kirby
Via USPS Mail
The staff of the Freedom of Information Advisory Council
is authorized to issue advisory opinions. The ensuing
staff advisory opinion is based solely upon the information
presented in your letter dated April 11, 2026.
Questions Presented
-
Whether Hanover County violated FOIA by failing
to provide any response to my March 31,
2026, request.
-
Whether a county attorney may lawfully instruct
a FOIA officer not to respond to a valid FOIA
request.
-
Whether repeated refusals to respond constitute
a pattern or practice of FOIA non-compliance
under § 2.2-3713 of the Code of Virginia.
-
Whether detailed accounting, consulting, and legal
fee records of a Community Development
Authority are public records subject to mandatory
disclosure.
Statement of Facts
In
your letter to this office dated April 11, 2026, you
included the following attachments:
-
Your March 31, 2026, FOIA request
-
Your April 10, 2026, follow-up email
-
Correspondence from the Hanover County Attorney
to you dated March 23, 2021, and September 10, 2021
As
the correspondence from 2021 does not relate to the
specific FOIA request at issue here, we acknowledge
its inclusion in your letter but will not discuss
it further.
Regarding your March 31, 2026, letter, it appears
that you made a FOIA request to Hanover County (County)
in which you asked for the "details, including
payees and amounts" corresponding to a specific
line item of the Bell Creek Community Development
Authority (CDA) entitled "Accounting, consulting,
and legal fees." That line item totaled $49,957
for fiscal year 2024 and $55,848 for fiscal year 2025.
After receiving no response from the County, you sent
a follow-up email on April 10, 2026, requesting a
response, which you state was not acknowledged. You
then sought the opinion of this office on four separate
questions, which will be examined below.
Applicable Law and Discussion
1.
Whether Hanover County violated FOIA by failing to
provide any response to my March 31, 2026, request.
Advisory
opinions from this office are based on the facts presented,
and you stated that the County did not respond. Pursuant
to subsection B of § 2.2-3704 of the Code of
Virginia, a public body must provide one of five required
responses, summarized as follows: (i) provide the
records; (ii) withhold the records entirely; (iii)
provide the records in part and withhold them in part;
(iv) state that the records cannot be found or do
not exist; or (v) invoke additional time to respond.
Your request for records was reasonably specific;
you invoked the privileges of FOIA when you made your
request, and so, the public body should have responded
within five working days as required by subsection
B of § 2.2-3704. Subsection E of the same section
provides that "[f]ailure to respond to a request
for records shall be deemed a denial of the request
and shall constitute a violation of this chapter."
Given the facts you have presented, and following
the plain language of § 2.2-3704, yes, it appears
that the County would be in violation for failing
to respond.
2.
Whether a county attorney may lawfully instruct a
FOIA officer not to respond to a valid FOIA request.
No, a county attorney may not lawfully instruct a
FOIA officer not to respond to a valid FOIA request
because such action would violate both the letter
and spirit of FOIA. FOIA policy, as stated in subsection
B of § 2.2-3700 of the Code of Virginia, is to
ensure "the people of the Commonwealth ready
access to public records in the custody of a public
body or its officers and employees." Subsection
B also includes the following: "The affairs of
government are not intended to be conducted in an
atmosphere of secrecy since at all times the public
is to be the beneficiary of any action taken at any
level of government." The policy statement further
provides that "[a]ll public records and meetings
shall be presumed open, unless an exemption is properly
invoked" and that "no record shall be withheld
or meeting closed to the public unless specifically
made exempt pursuant to this chapter or other specific
provision of law." The policy is implemented
by the procedure stated in subsection A of §
2.2-3704 ("Except as otherwise specifically provided
by law, all public records shall be open…") and
the redaction rule expressed in § 2.2-3704.01:
No
provision of this chapter is intended, nor shall
it be construed or applied, to authorize a public
body to withhold a public record in its entirety
on the grounds that some portion of the public record
is excluded from disclosure by this chapter or by
any other provision of law. A public record may
be withheld from disclosure in its entirety only
to the extent that an exclusion from disclosure
under this chapter or other provision of law applies
to the entire content of the public record. Otherwise,
only those portions of the public record containing
information subject to an exclusion under this chapter
or other provision of law may be withheld, and all
portions of the public record that are not so excluded
shall be disclosed.
As
previously stated, subsection E of § 2.2-3704
provides that a failure to respond to a request is
deemed to be a denial of the request and a violation
of FOIA. FOIA does not have any provision that would
allow a public body simply not to respond to a request
unless the requester owes an outstanding balance for
prior requests. In that situation, subsection I of
§ 2.2-3704 provides that "[b]efore processing
a request for records, a public body may require the
requester to pay any amounts owed to the public body
for previous requests for records that remain unpaid
30 days or more after billing." Thus, if a county
attorney were to instruct a FOIA officer not to respond
to a FOIA request that meets the requirements of subsection
B of § 2.2-3704, namely that a request "identify
the requested records with reasonable specificity,"
that instruction would violate the policy and procedural
requirements of FOIA, except in the situation where
the requester owes an outstanding balance for prior
requests.
3.
Whether repeated refusals to respond constitute a
pattern or practice of FOIA non-compliance under §
2.2-3713 of the Code of Virginia.
As we have repeatedly affirmed, this office is not
a trier of fact.1 Moreover, our enabling statute does
not grant this office investigatory authority.2 For
those reasons, this office may address whether alleged
acts would violate FOIA under the facts presented,
but it cannot investigate or adjudicate whether disputed
events collectively establish a pattern of non-compliance.
That fact-intensive determination is properly reserved
for a court.3 However, note that the language of subsection
D of § 2.2-3713 of the Code of Virginia states
"[a] single instance of denial of the rights
and privileges conferred by this chapter shall be
sufficient to invoke the remedies granted herein."
Given that provision, a court may issue an appropriate
order whenever it finds a violation has occurred,
even if a pattern or practice of violations is not
demonstrated. As stated by the Supreme Court of Virginia,
"once a violation of VFOIA has been established,
whether an injunction is warranted is a question committed
to the trial court's discretion."4
Thus,
if you believe that your FOIA rights have been violated,
the statutory remedy provided in § 2.2-3713 is
to file a petition for mandamus or injunction in either
general district or circuit court (petitioner's choice).
The courts publish a sample form and instructions
for use in general district court, which we have linked
on the Forms and Sample Letters webpage. Please do
not hesitate to contact us if you have any questions
or need additional information, but please be advised,
as with any other type of court proceeding, you may
wish to consult your own attorney before deciding
whether to file a petition.
4.
Whether detailed accounting, consulting, and legal
fee records of a Community Development Authority are
public records subject to mandatory disclosure.
The definition of "public record" in §
2.2-3701 of the Code of Virginia includes all types
of records "however stored, and regardless of
physical form or characteristics, prepared or owned
by, or in the possession of a public body or its officers,
employees, or agents in the transaction of public
business." Therefore, the answer to this question
is yes, if these Community Development Authority (CDA)
records meet the definition of "public records"
(i.e., they exist and are prepared or owned by, or
in the possession of, the CDA in the transaction of
public business). However, it appears that you asked
for the CDA records from Hanover County, which may
not actually possess the records you seek (keeping
in mind that the CDA and the County are separate political
subdivisions and public bodies).
As
stated above, your original FOIA request mentioned
specific line items in the CDA's financial statements.
Your FOIA request asked the County to provide supporting
records detailing the "payees and amounts"
that "make up" the line items from those
financial statements. More specifically, the request
read as follows:
"Ms.
Randolph, financial statements for the Bell Creek
Community Development Authority for fy 2024 and
2025. In the statement of Revenues, Expenses, and
Changes in Net Position, a line item "Accounting,
consulting and legal fees" Amounts for 2024
$49,957 and for 2025, $55,848. Please provide the
details, including payee and amounts that make up
the above numbers. Provide an estimate of my costs."
In this case, the correct response from the County,
if it does not in fact have the requested financial
records, would have been that they did not possess
the records and to direct you to contact the CDA instead.
Conclusion
If the County did not respond to your initial FOIA
request as you have asserted, that failure to respond
would be deemed a denial of your request and a violation
of FOIA as provided by subsection E of § 2.2-3704
of the Code of Virginia. It is for a court to decide
the appropriate remedy for the deficiency of conduct
you have outlined. When a public body does not possess
the public records that a requester seeks and knows
that those records are held by another public body,
it must notify the requester of this fact and provide
contact information for the other public body as required
by subdivision B 3 of § 2.2-3704.
Sincerely,
Matteo
Murrelle
Staff Attorney
Alan
Gernhardt, Esq.
Executive Director
1See
Freedom of Information Advisory Opinions 04 (2024),
01 (2023), 01 (2022), 01 (2021), 05 (2017), 03 (2016),
04 (2015), 02 (2015), 02 (2013), and 09 (2005).
2See Va. Code Ann. § 30-179.
3See Freedom of Information Advisory
Opinions 02 (2013), 01 (2018), 01 (2020).
4Suffolk City Sch. Bd. v. Wahlstrom,
302 Va. 188 at 210, 886 S.E.2d 244 at 256-257 (Va.
2023).
|